Will whenever dates are supplied, he is offered that have day of one’s day you to do not fits with this date because into the real history. One particular example takes place in Harry Potter and also the Prisoner away from Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney identifies sixteen October once the Saturday, although 16 Oct 1993 is actually a monday.
There are even contradictions for the books in this area. Like, for the Harry Potter and Goblet of Flames, one another step 1 Sep and 2 Sep are supplied given that Mondays and you will, inside Harry Potter as well as the Prisoner out of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is decided to your 20 April, but mindful parsing of one’s text message indicates that it could features taken place zero after than just February.
And additionally, in Harry Potter and the Goblet from Flame people say that the Winners was indeed picked on the Saturday 31 Oct, but 31 Oct is a saturday when you look at the 1994.
From inside the chapter 7 regarding Quidditch From the Years, they state the very first Quidditch Globe Glass was held for the 1473. In the event your title is kept all the four years, so it problems on the statement into the Cup from Flames your 1994 Business Glass was the brand new 422nd. If Quidditch Through the Decades is good, brand new 422nd Quidditch Globe Cup do in reality fall-in the season 3161, however, if Goblet out-of Flame excellent, the initial Community Cup was actually held into the 306.
Historic trouble [ ]
Whilst the Korea kvinner show, with respect to the schedule based on the new Chamber off Secrets reference, is decided regarding the 1990s, the new collection tend to looks as though it is invest brand new late nineties to help you middle-2000s, around concurrent on publication of one’s instructions. Within the Harry Potter and 1 / 2 of-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a masculine pronoun to refer towards the “predecessor” of one’s Best Minister of Uk. With respect to the a lot more than schedule, this will take place in the summer months regarding 1996, when the Prime Minister are John Biggest, whose immediate ancestor is actually a female (‘s very first ending up in Fudge, the ebook states the election, however, Major wasn’t initially decided to go with and only took over shortly after Thatcher retired.
You are able, however unrealistic, that Fudge would-be talking about a very distant predecessor, given that Thatcher got office just before Fudge allegedly became Minister to possess Magic. (Though you can thought a scenario where Fudge was delegated from the Minister to possess Secret to meet into Primary Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller work environment.) On top of that, the fresh identity and you will reputation for the prime Minister represented appears to even more closely suits compared to Tony Blair than simply of John Significant. A blog post about Each and every day Mail notes one Rowling was personal toward up coming-Chancellor of one’s Exchequer Gordon Brownish (tend to seen as a competition so you’re able to Blair’s leadership of the Labor Cluster, just who succeeded him and became Finest Minister), and this she has been trying to inform you Blair’s bad front side. If your books was indeed invest connect that have publication day regarding Philosopher’s Stone, following this experience do take place in 2002 (immediately after Blair turned into Prime Minister).
But not, it actually was later stated that twenty two November try a monday, which it was in 1994
An equivalent state comes to Nicolas Flamel, who had been stated to be 665 during the fresh earliest book, however, Nicolas Flamel is a bona fide historical shape and you can won’t reach you to definitely ages up until 1996, in the day the original guide is actually wrote. This new rebuttal for it is that the go out new “real” Nicolas Flamel was given birth to does not correspond with the new Nicolas Flamel off Harry Potter.
An alternative disease can be obtained of Rubeus Hagrid’s period once the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s created on the show that Hagrid was given one condition within a couple of years away from their expulsion of university in the 1942. In you to scene out-of Harry Potter and the Goblet regarding Fire, Molly Weasley reminisces from the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper seem to convergence that have Molly’s many years at school, it looks unlikely you to she remembers a past gamekeeper. Although not, it is possible that Hagrid did not be good gamekeeper instantaneously immediately following are expelled, but instead become while the Ogg’s secretary. This is probable given that whenever Harry believes which he commonly getting expelled for traveling toward broomstick without consent inside the first year, the guy secret if he would be permitted to stay on due to the fact Hagrid’s assistant.